• magpie
Grand Canyon Wolf Recovery Project

Local & Regional News

Commission follows politics, not science

Print Email

Arizona Daily Sun (Original) Letter to the Editor Posted August 19, 2015 by Toni Prothero

To the editor:

Thank you for the recent article by Dave Parsons regarding the recovery of the Mexican wolf in Arizona. Mr. Parsons is a scientist with direct experience of the efforts to recover this species and well-qualified to critique the decisions of policymakers like Arizona Game and Fish Commission and Representative Gosar.

I attended the recent meeting of the Commission in Flagstaff and was appalled at their decision to oppose any more releases of adult wolves from captive breeding facilities and to rely solely on cross-fostering of captive-born pups. This is a very difficult technique to accomplish and, in fact, failed this year.

I have no doubt that many excellent people work for Arizona Game and Fish and work hard for the Mexican wolf's recovery, but the Commission is another matter. They are political appointees and their decisions are based on politics and not on peer-reviewed science, which is quite clear as to what is needed to save the species: access to suitable habitat north of I-40, an end to killings and removals, at least two more populations with the ability to intermingle among the populations, and expedited releases of adults from captivity for the genetic rescue of the species.

None of these points is evident in the Commission's plans -- quite the opposite, in fact. The current population of Mexican wolves is very small and vulnerable. We cannot afford to let them slip away into extinction as almost occurred before. The Commission would better serve the people of Arizona by following the science.

TONI PROTHERO

Flagstaff

Theology, biology agree on wolves

Print Email

Arizona Daily Sun (Original) Letter to the Editor Posted August 15, 2015 by Sarah King

To the editor:

I read with interest the guest columns presenting opposing views on the Arizona Game and Fish Commission's deliberations (and recent decision) on the future of the Mexican gray wolf recovery program. Both writers presented scientific facts -- and in one case, misstatements of fact -- to back up their conclusions. I'd like to add a different voice to the debate -- the theological one.

Mexican wolves still threatened by Gosar bill

Print Email

Arizona Daily Sun (Original) Special Posted on August 13, 2015 by David Parsons

In his August 6 op-ed, David Wolf presents the "facts" about Mexican wolf recovery. Alas, one person's facts are often another's fiction. I don't know Mr. Wolf's credentials. I have a Master of Science degree in wildlife biology and served as Mexican Wolf Recovery Coordinator for the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service from 1990-1999. I have followed the recovery program ever since, and am a member of the Mexican Wolf Recovery Team.

Mr. Wolf claims wild Mexican wolves' "survival and reproductive potential has increased many fold over the pen-raised wolves the program started with in 1998." This claim has not been proven, but we do know that the wild population is highly inbred and that without new releases of captive wolves, each new wild generation becomes increasingly inbred. Currently, wild Mexican wolves are on average as related as brothers and sisters. Important genetically diverse Mexican wolves are available in captivity, but new releases have been restricted for many years by the Arizona Game Commission, which at its last meeting prohibited the additional releases of captive adult wolves and allowed only six captive-born pups to be released annually by placing them with wild litters in their dens—a tricky experimental technique called "cross fostering." So far, there has been one placement of two pups in a den and one surviving pup has been confirmed. There is no scientific foundation for the Commission's edict.

Mr. Wolf is correct that the "core" of historical Mexican wolf habitat is in Mexico. However, habitats with the highest potential for recovering Mexican wolves are in the United States. Scientists (some from Mexico) appointed by the Fish and Wildlife Service to the Mexican Wolf Recovery Team concluded that additional habitats in northern Arizona / southern Utah and northern New Mexico / southern Colorado are essential to recovery and long-term survival of Mexican wolves.

Mr. Wolf asserts that Arizona Game and Fish Department "is more than capable of and will see the program to a successful conclusion." The department assumed authority over management decisions for the wild population from 2003 to 2009. The wild population exactly matched projections at 55 wolves in 2003. Six years later, it declined to 42 wolves, which led to a federal court settlement that returned management authority to the Fish and Wildlife Service. Two years later, the population was back to the 2003 level. Eight years of the 17-year reintroduction effort were wasted and important genetic diversity squandered under state control.

If Representative Gosar succeeds in taking Mexican wolves off of the Federal endangered species list, their extinction would be likely.

David Parsons is a retired wildlife biologist who lives in New Mexico.

Wolves far from in recovery

Print Email

Arizona Daily Sun (Original) Letter to the Editor Posted on August 7, 2015 by Roxane George

To the editor:

How ironic that David Wolf's August 6th column claiming to present "the facts" on the status of Mexican gray wolves is itself rife with fallacies. The most glaring of these is Wolf's claim that with only 109 Mexican gray wolves in a single population in the wild, and another 250 in captivity, they are no longer close to extinction. They are, in fact, one of the world's most endangered wolves, and they desperately need the federal protections Gosar's bill would remove.

Like Arizona Game and Fish, Wolf implies that we need not recover our native wolves in the Southwest because a significant portion of the lobo's historic habitat was in Mexico. This is indicative of a mindset that still sees wolves as a problem to be rid of, rather than important, intelligent animals that can help make our wildlands whole, and our deer and elk herds healthy. Thousands of these wolves roamed the Southwest prior to European settlement. They belong here.

While Arizona Game and Fish biologists contribute greatly to Mexican wolf reintroduction, the politically appointed Commission has repeatedly acted to subvert wolf recovery. Just one day after Wolf's column was published, the Commission voted to keep genetically valuable adult wolves in captivity while the wild population becomes increasingly genetically impoverished.

Our lobos need genetic rescue, two new populations north of I-40, and a science-based recovery plan. They don't need barriers to recovery erected by Arizona's Game and Fish Commission or misleading newspaper columns about their plight.

ROXANE GEORGE

Flagstaff

Press Release: Mexican Gray Wolf Supporters Rally at Arizona Game and Fish Meeting

Print Email

Arizonans Protest Commission's Interference with Wolf Recovery.

For Immediate Release: August 7, 2015

Contacts for members of the media:
Emily Renn, Grand Canyon Wolf Recovery Project, This email address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it.
Al White, former Flagstaff Vice-Mayor, This email address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it.
Sarah King, Earth Care Commission-AZ SAFE Network, This email address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it.
Roxane George, Mexicanwolves.org, This email address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it.

Mexican Gray Wolf Supporters Rally at Arizona Game and Fish Meeting

Arizonans Protest Commission's Interference with Wolf Recovery

FLAGSTAFF, AZ — Wildlife supporters from across the state, including scientists and activists from the Grand Canyon Wolf Recovery Project, Sierra Club, Great Old Broads for Wilderness, and Grand Canyon Wildlands Council, rallied Friday at the Arizona Game and Fish Commission meeting at Little America to protest the commissioners' actions to undermine the Mexican gray wolf reintroduction and recovery, and to express their support for the highly endangered wolves.

Grand Canyon Wolf Recovery Project executive director Emily Renn told the large crowd of wolf supporters, "With only 110 in the wild, Mexican gray wolves are one of the most endangered wolves in the world. They are beautiful, intelligent animals that, given a chance, can help restore the health of our wild lands and keep elk and deer populations in balance. But we need an Arizona Game and Fish Commission that doesn't just pay lip service to wolf recovery while its actions endanger the wolves' survival."

More Articles...

  1. Wolves backed by science, public
  2. Utah hunter who killed gray wolf won't be charged
  3. No charges against Utah cougar hunter who killed Echo the wandering wolf: “I had a shot and took it.”
  4. Removing wolf protection will be lethal
  5. Gosar bill is wolf in sheep’s clothing
  6. More killed by cows than wolves
  7. Managing wolves means better data
  8. Why not simply release more wolves?
  9. Cross-fostering pups a partial solution
  10. Wolf adoption becomes part of species recovery plan
  11. Release more wolves from captivity
  12. Missouri site helping effort to repopulate US wolves
  13. Press Release: A Celebration of Our Environment!
  14. Opinion: The wolf’s journey ends in Utah
  15. Lessons From the Brief, Lonesome Life of Echo the Wolf
  16. Press Release: Endangered Mexican gray wolf population reaches 109
  17. Wolf killed in Utah was animal from rare Arizona sighting
  18. Press Release: Confirmed - Echo, the First Wolf in Over 70 years at Grand Canyon, Is Dead
  19. What's a wolf to do? Go vegan, apparently
  20. Wolves get more area to roam in Ariz., N.M.
  21. OPINION: Who has lived long enough to listen objectively to the howl of a wolf?
  22. Hoooowl no! Canyon wolf may have been killed
  23. Press Release: Grand Canyon Wolf Named “Echo” in World-wide Contest
  24. Rules allowing wolf kills loosened
  25. Study: Wolf kills might not work
  26. Press Release: Endangered Mexican Gray Wolf Rule Would Hinder Species Recovery
  27. Gray Wolf Near Grand Canyon’s North Rim Endured Long, Harrowing Journey
  28. Press Release: DNA Tests Confirm First Wolf in Over 70 years is Living near Grand Canyon’s North Rim
  29. Wolves, livestock have coexisted elsewhere
  30. Gray wolves return to Grand Canyon?
  31. Gray Wolf Spotted in Grand Canyon for First Time in Decades?
  32. Wolf-like animal seen roaming in northern Arizona
  33. Like fox guarding the henhouse
  34. Wolves, antelope can co-exist
  35. Putting wolves on North Kaibab now might work better
  36. Wolf Expansion Long Overdue
  37. Feds: No wolves to roam in Grand Canyon
  38. Federal Plan Would Expand Wolf Territory in Arizona, New Mexico
  39. Let wild wolves roam in wilderness
  40. Editorial: Game and Fish Should Wait For Full Wolf EIS
  41. State: No Mexican gray wolves for Flagstaff area
  42. Guest Column: Game and Fish plan makes it easier to kill wolves
  43. Guest Opinion: Game and Fish can't be trusted with wolf program
  44. Wild Battle Rages Over Wolves, Wilderness And Politics Of Extinction
  45. Brewer vetoes bill letting ranchers kill endangered wolves on federal lands
  46. Wolves make the elk herd strong
  47. State Legislature Attempts to Limit Federal Wolf Reintroduction
  48. Alpha wolf pack sighted in Flagstaff
  49. Wolf Wanderers blog post
  50. Letter to the Editor: Thorpe's wolf story too one-sided
  51. Anti-wolf bills clear case of over-reaction
  52. House should listen to public on wolf issue
  53. Bob Thorpe trims wolf proposal
  54. Legislators work to cap gray wolves in Arizona
  55. Denying federal authority costly, inconsistent
  56. Wolves are in the crosshairs, thanks to Sen. Gail Griffin
  57. Thorpe takes up cause of Arizona ranchers losing cattle to wolves
  58. Wolf plan reignites passions
  59. National Wolf Awareness Week Event to Affect the Future of Wolves in AZ
  60. Mexican gray wolf: Where the wild things aren’t
  61. New study forecasts genetic risks to wolves in western US unless dispersal can connect isolated populations
  62. Letter to the Editor: Writer's wolf argument holds water
  63. Coconino Voices: Wolves deserve wider range
  64. Letter to the Editor: Let wolves roam more widely
  65. Editorial: Wolf expansion plan needs more details
  66. Wolves to roam toward Flagstaff?
  67. Arizona Endangered Wolves Still On The Brink
  68. Press Release: Scientists Call on Obama Administration to Keep Gray Wolves Protected Under Endangered Species Act
  69. Sedona Lecture Series focuses on Mexican Gray Wolf – April 8
  70. Howling-Good Films: Wild and Scenic Film Festival Visits Flagstaff and Benefits Local Wolf Recovery Project
  71. 15 Years of Mexican Gray Wolves: Celebrate or Sob?
  72. Arizona commission backs request to remove wolves from endangered list
  73. Wolves in Utah
  74. Attempt to strip dollars for anti-wolf lobbyist fails
  75. Why keep wolves out?
  76. Editorial: Just cry wolf
  77. Anti-wolf group likely to get second $300,000 Utah payment
  78. Legislators steering another $300,000 to anti-wolf crusade
  79. Expert: Still a Long Road Ahead for Mexican Wolf Recovery
  80. Why not control elk with wolves?
  81. Number Rose for Endangered Wolves in 2012
  82. Elk Targeted Over Aspen
  83. Grand Canyon Elk Go From Attraction To Menace
  84. Team's daily job is to manage wolves back from the brink of extinction
  85. Idea for Wolf Diversity Draws Ire
  86. We can still save the Mexican gray wolf
  87. Follow the Trail
  88. Reintroduce wolves to control bison
  89. Canyon backcountry users weigh in on access
  90. Delisting Mexican wolves sets dangerous precedent
  91. Mexican gray wolves deserve protection
  92. Wolves in wilderness part of divine splendor
  93. Coconino Voices: Wolves on rise but far away from recovery
  94. Arizona's wolves need a break
  95. Game and Fish abandoning gray wolves
  96. Mexican gray wolves due more protection
  97. Don't give wolf opponents tracking frequencies
  98. Song of the wolf long overdue here
  99. Wolf return connects us to natural world
  100. North Rim wolf revival?

Action and Events

e-News Alert List

Email address:

First Name:

Last Name:


Donate Today

Please click the button below to be taken to our secure, encrypted PayPal page. Input the donation amount you would like to donate. If you would like to make this a monthly donation, please check mark the box next to the amount input field. Donations may be tax-deductible.

Restoring the Balance

blah- not used

Close Panel

Login Form